[Structured Discussion] Distribute LBP unsold tokens to the people who contributed to the LBP in proportion to their contribution

👩‍⚖️ Governance ⚡ Proposal Drafts
6

@all_in_radicle If someone bought the LBP in first todays,and then sold them out . I don’t think this guy should get the Distrubtion. it’s unfair for the people who still hold the RAD even the RAD prices is going down everyday. I suggest the token only distbuted to the people who bought in first two days and still not sell untill now.

1 Like
7

Yeah, that makes sense and your argument is same as @thepleb’s one if I understand correctly :slight_smile: And I now think that we should only include these people bought in first 2 days who still hold it.

2 Likes
8

I think This proposal for Holder only , Anyone who has been sold will not receive this opportunity.

1 Like
9

I think 1/1800 is super unfair.!!! some one bought 1 RAD as the same right as who with 1000 RADS. Why i bought a lot RAD to support this project?

10

Hi guys, welcome to join this discussion, the options below have moved to [Structured Discussion] Distribute LBP unsold tokens to the people who contributed to the LBP in proportion to their contribution - #42 by onur, if you want to share your opinion on this topic, vote on it please~

The open question might need a format, for example

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

I can’t tell the reason, but I don’t think we should distribute all unsold tokens to the LBP contributors, maybe 5% ~ 50%? I don’t know if the snapshot support embedded checkboxes.

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper limit
  • [ ] no
7 Likes
11

This is great, thanks @clearloop! My answers are:

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged
    I’m fine with both. RAD would more make sense given the token sale was on LBP.

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
    I was thinking a bit about this but the reason for no limit is to be “fair”. As long as we eliminate those who have already sold their tokens, good whales should be welcomed. But if community is uncomfortable with that, I believe 10,000 RAD limit will include all tokens for 99% holders and prevent the whales to skew the distribution.
4 Likes
12

This is great, thanks @clearloop! My answers are:

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
13

I am strongly support your opinion!

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
14

This is great, I am.a LBP holder.and glad to see the final result @clearloop! My reply as below

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
15

That’s good offer.
My answers are:

  1. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?
  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%
  1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?
  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no
  1. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged
    I’m fine with both. RAD would more make sense given the token sale was on LBP.
  1. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
16

As i know there 49% left, is that your 50% means the whole of total unsold or 50% of unsold token?

My Answer?
0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50% Here i choose whole unsold which is 49%
  1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?
  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no
  1. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged
    I’m fine with both. RAD would more make sense given the token sale was on LBP.
  1. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
17

I am strongly support your opinion!

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
18

My answers are:

  1. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?
  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%
  1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?
  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no
  1. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged
    I’m fine with both. RAD would more make sense given the token sale was on LBP.
  1. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?
  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
19

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 100%. Should be whatever is left for the unsold, right?

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
1 Like
20

support :+1:

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
21

support 100%

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
22

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no
2 Likes
23

This is great, thanks @clearloop! My answers are:

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [√ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ √] yes → upper
  • [ ] no
24

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓] yes → upper
  • [ ] no
25

0. Distribute how many unsold tokens to the LBP contributors?

  • [ ] 5%
  • [ ] 15%
  • [ ] 30%
  • [✓ ] 50%

1. Should we distribute tokens to the LBP contributors who have already sold their tokens?

  • [ ] yes
  • [✓ ] no

2. How many tokens should we distribute to one LBP contributor?

  • [✓ ] Depends on how many RAD he/she exchanged
  • [✓ ] Depends on how many USDC he/she exchanged
    I’m fine with both. RAD would more make sense given the token sale was on LBP.

3. Should we set a limit for distributing RAD to one LBP contributor?

  • [ ] yes → upper
  • [✓ ] no